Head to https://brilliant.org/wallstreetmillennial to start your free 30-day trial, and the first 200 people get 20% off an annual premium subscription.
In this video we go over the recent strikes by the UAW against the big three US automakers: Ford, GM, and Stellantis. We look at what this could mean for non-unionized automakers like Tesla as well as the US auto industry in general.
0:00 - 2:43 Intro
2:44 - 5:53 History of UAW
5:54 - 10:35 Transition to EVs
10:36 Tesla
Check out our second channel Broken Business Models where we discuss unusual or otherwise suspect businesses that may be unviable: https://www.youtube.com/ @BrokenBusinessModels
Email us: Wallstreetmillennial @gmail.com
Check out our new podcast on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4UZL13dUPYW1s4XtvHcEwt?si=08579cc0424d4999&nd=1
All materials in these videos are used for educational purposes and fall within the guidelines of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. If you are or represent the copyright owner of materials used in this video and have a problem with the use of said material, please send me an email, wallstreetmillennial.com, and we can sort it out.
#Wallstreetmillennial #uawstrike #tesla #automobiles #electricvehicle
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
Buddha by Kontekst https://soundcloud.com/kontekstmusic
Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported — CC BY-SA 3.0
Free Download / Stream: http://bit.ly/2Pe7mBN
Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/b6jK2t3lcRs
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
In this video we go over the recent strikes by the UAW against the big three US automakers: Ford, GM, and Stellantis. We look at what this could mean for non-unionized automakers like Tesla as well as the US auto industry in general.
0:00 - 2:43 Intro
2:44 - 5:53 History of UAW
5:54 - 10:35 Transition to EVs
10:36 Tesla
Check out our second channel Broken Business Models where we discuss unusual or otherwise suspect businesses that may be unviable: https://www.youtube.com/ @BrokenBusinessModels
Email us: Wallstreetmillennial @gmail.com
Check out our new podcast on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4UZL13dUPYW1s4XtvHcEwt?si=08579cc0424d4999&nd=1
All materials in these videos are used for educational purposes and fall within the guidelines of fair use. No copyright infringement intended. If you are or represent the copyright owner of materials used in this video and have a problem with the use of said material, please send me an email, wallstreetmillennial.com, and we can sort it out.
#Wallstreetmillennial #uawstrike #tesla #automobiles #electricvehicle
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
Buddha by Kontekst https://soundcloud.com/kontekstmusic
Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported — CC BY-SA 3.0
Free Download / Stream: http://bit.ly/2Pe7mBN
Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/b6jK2t3lcRs
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
On September 14th, 2023, the United Auto Workers or UAW announced strikes which crippled production at the big three Us automakers GM Ford and Stellantis, previously known as Chrysler. The UAW complains that their 150,000 members have seen stagnant wages over the past decade which have not kept up with inflation. They are demanding a 40% wage increase, a 4-day work week, cost of living adjustments, greater job security, and defined benefit pension plans Ford CEO Jim Far said that accepting the Union's demands would bankrupt the company, as it would be impossible for them to compete with non-unionized automakers. The domestic cost of labor for the big three automakers currently sits at $64 per hour.
Non-unionized automakers like Tesla have an estimated labor cost of $50 per hour. The Uaw's demand would increase the cost to $150 per hour, more than triple their non-union competitors. At the same time, the Big Three need to spend tens of billions of dollars to transition into electric vehicles. Over the coming years, they've been planning to use the profits from their internal combustion engine cars to fund this transition, but if they agree to the Union's demands, even their internal combustion engine Vehicles will lose money.
But the union refuses to back down and has categorically rejected counter proposals from the automakers. In this video, we'll look at the existential threat the UAW poses to the Big three automakers and how this plays to the benefit of non-unionized EV Makers like Tesla The transition to electric vehicles shows how important it is to Pace with the everchanging world of technology, Engineers who used to work on internal combustion engines now need to change their focus to battery and digital Technologies to remain relevant. Luckily, the best way to stay up toate on the latest technological Concepts doesn't require thousands of dollars or years of schooling. It's actually free and easy.
Brilliant is the best way to learn math, data science, and computer science. It's fun and interactive with thousands of lessons from Basics to Advanced Topics in new lessons added every month. I've particularly enjoyed their How Technology Works courses which teach teach you how electronic components like transistors and capacitors work. It also teaches you practical things like why some passwords are more resistant to hackers than others.
Many of the Technologies we use in our daily lives are like black boxes as we have no idea how they function. But with Brilliant, you can begin to understand what's going on at a fundamental level. The Interactive Learning that Brilliant provides is proven to be six times more effective than passive learning like watching lecture videos. This means that you can Master big Concepts in as little as 15 minutes per day to try every everything Brilliant has to offer free for a full 30 days visit Brilliant.org Wall Street Millennial or click on the link in the description.
The first 200 of you will get 20% off Brilliant's annual premium subscription. The UAW was founded in the 1930s and quickly organize workers from Ford GM and Chrysler The union elects Representatives who negotiate with the automakers on behalf of their members. If the automakers are unwilling to meet the Union's pay demands, the union will strike, refusing to work. In recent decades, foreign automakers like Toyota and Nissan as well as new companies like Tesla have set up factories in the US. The UAW has attempted to unionize these new plants, but for the most part these efforts have failed. Non-unionized automakers pay their workers only about 10 to 20% Less in their Union counterparts, of which 1.4% goes to union dues. Thus, the benefit for joining the union is only limited and many workers fear that the union may cause the automaker to shut down the factory altogether. Thus, the American Auto industry has been segregated into two sections: The Big Three Automakers had to negotiate with the UAW while for the most part, all other automakers don't Throughout the 1990s and 2000s, American automakers started to lose market share to foreign competitors.
This was in part due to poor design choices, but some blame must be given to the UAW. By 2008, the average cost of labor at UAW plants was $10 per hour greater than cars made in Europe or Japan. This came to a head with the 2008 Great Recession. With the The Big Three already paying too much to their workers, they were hit hard when unemployment Rose and automobile demand collapsed.
Ultimately, GM and Chrysler declared bankruptcy and were forced to accept government bailouts. In an effort to save the industry, the government negotiated a deal with the UAW to significantly decreased their wages going forward. This agreement included a substantial decrease in hourly wages for new workers, the elimination of defined benefit pension plans, and a removal of cost of living adjustments which previously increased wages each year in line with inflation. In 2007, the average cost per hour of labor at UAW factories was $78 To be clear, nobody was getting paid $78 per hour.
The maximum wage was only $28 but you also have to consider the cost of employer provided Healthcare employer contributions to Define Benefit pension plans and paid time off. After the 2009 deal, the average cost decreased substantially to $56 per hour. The non-salary benefits were reduced substantially, and new workers were paid much lower wages as low as $17 per hour. UAW Wages stayed stagnant for the next 10 years as the automakers were still recovering from the financial crisis and had no means to increase wages.
In 2019, the UAW finally negotiated a significant increase, but average compensation is still far below 2008 levels and this brings us to the current situation. In 20123, the UAW elected a new president sha Fain who is demanding massive pay and benefit increase es. He complains that the big three automakers are making record profits in increasing the salaries of senior Executives At the same time, UAW Workers have seen a pay cut in real terms as their wages have not kept pace with inflation. This strike comes at the worst possible time for the Big Three, as they're already losing billions of dollars on their electric vehicles, which has put them in a precarious financial position already. In recent years, the big three automakers have been investing heavily in electric vehicles in an effort to compete with. Tesla Transitioning to EVS has become a priority with countries in Europe as well as California planning to ban the sale of internal combustion engine cars by 20135, the Legacy automakers need to invest tens of billions of dollars to repurpose their factories to build. EVS Additionally, their lacking Battery Technology currently puts them at a severe cost disadvantage compared to Tesla. For example, in the first half of 2023, Ford sold 47,000 electric vehicles.
This is the most out of any of the big three, but it still represents just 2% of their total sales. The average selling price was $53,000 but it cost them $91,000 to make each vehicle, leading to a $388,000 per vehicle loss. As it turns out, electric vehicles are actually easier to build than internal combustion engine cars. They have less parts and require 40% less labor to assemble.
The reason they cost so much more is because of the batteries. Most Us automakers, including Ford currently import their batteries from abroad, but this is very expensive. Earlier this year, Ford announced that they'll be spending $3.5 billion to build their own battery. Factory in Michigan Licensing Technology from the Chinese Battery Company.
Catl the factory was expected to come online in 2026. By making the batteries themselves, the cost will be much lower. Jobs at the new battery factories could replace many of the jobs lost on the assembly lines. As part of the negotiations, Shan Fain is demanding that wages at these battery plants must be the same or higher than the wages that they are demanding for existing Ford factories.
This is despite the fact that the workers at these new battery factories have not voted to join the UAW as they do not yet exist. as the UAW negotiation stalled, Ford halted construction on their new battery. Factory They won't continue construction until they have certainty that they can operate it competitively. Basically, Ford is saying that if the UAW gets the wages at once, it would be impossible to make electric vehicles profitably.
Thus far, the UAW and automakers can't come to an agreement. The automakers say that the Union's demand would bankrupt them. The UAW says the automakers are making record profits and CEO compensation has increased. While wages for production workers have remain stagnant, the CEO compensation issue is a distraction. The highest paid of the big three is GM CEO Mary bar who made $29 Million last year. While you can argue about whether or not this is excessive, it's a rounding error compared to the tens of billions of dollars that they paid to UAW workers. On the issue of record profits, It is true that the Big Three had a great year in 2022. For example, Ford's North America segment generated $9 billion of pre-tax profit.
Although a lot of that profit came from cars made in Mexico. It is estimated that Uaw's demands would add roughly $20 billion per year of cost to each of the three automakers. that would turn the9 billion profit into an 11 billion loss. Not only that, but Ford plans to invest $50 billion over the next 3 years in an effort to transition onethird of their production to electric vehicles by 2026.
Remember, only 2% % of their vehicle sales are electric today, so it will be huge effort to reach this goal. The increasing difficulties with the UAW will likely push the Big 3 to shift more of their production. South Of the Border all the big three have factories in Mexico. The Usmca trade deal allows them to be exported to the US and Canada without tariffs.
The Mexican factories are also unionized, but wages in general are much lower. The starting wage is the equivalent of $3 per hour less than a fifth of the starting wage of UAW workers, even under the ex existing contract. As an example, Ford operates two factories in Mexico, making 400,000 cars per year, the vast majority of which are exported to the US and Canada. This is compared to 1.8 million cars that they make each year in the US.
If the UAW forces untenable wage increases, the Big three will have no choice but to lay off Us workers and move more production to Mexico. But this will only work for Internal Combustion Engine. Vehicles. The $7,500 EV tax credits from Biden's Inflation Reduction Act are are only eligible for cars assembled in the US.
This puts the Big Three in a difficult position as the industry transitions to EVS. They're already uncompetitive with Tesla and raising wages for UAW workers will make the situation even worse. The most obvious beneficiary is Tesla. It's in Tesla's interest for these Big Three to remain uncompetitive in electric vehicles so that they can maintain their dominant market share.
But surprisingly, Musk has come to the defense of the Big Three, calling the Uaw's demands ridiculous and saying the Big three will go bankrupt under the new terms. So why is Musk saying this? Why not just sit back and watch his competitor struggle? Tesla is an obvious beneficiary of the UAW strike in the short term, but in the long term, the story is a bit more complicated. In theory, there's nothing stopping Tesla's workers from joining the UAW if a majority of them vote in favor of this and if this happened, Tesla would end up in the same predicament as the Big 3. In 2017, some workers at Tesla's Fremont California Factory contacted the UAW and tried to organize a union vote. Elon Musk is a strong opponent of unions. He fired one of the employees involved in the union activism and put out a tweet saying that workers would lose their stock options if they unionized. a Court ruled that both of these actions were in violation of labor laws. If workers want to unionize, companies aren't allowed to stop them or retaliate against employees who vote in favor of unionization.
The reason that Tesla's workers have thus far failed to unionize is because under the existing contracts, UAW workers only get paid about 10 to 20% more than non-union workers. However, if the UAW secures a big pay raise, the Gap will widen significantly, providing a greater motivation to join the union. That's why Musk is so scared of the current strikes at the Big Three. With that being said, it's extremely unlikely that the UAW will secure anything close to what they are currently demanding, as the Big three simply can't afford it.
It's unclear what the UAW is realistically trying to accomplish with its current strikes. Regardless of the outcome of the negotiations, the Uaw's exessive demands will almost certainly accelerate the Outsourcing of internal combustion engine vehicle production to Mexico. It has cast serious doubt on the Big 3's plans to invest in electric vehicles. All right guys, that wraps it up for this video.
What do you think about the UAW strikes? Let us know in the comments section below. As always, thank you so much for watching and we'll see you in the next one. Wall Street Millennial Signing out.
Blaming the workers asking for living wages for US poor industrial performances. Smooth.
They're more profitable than ever lol
Sorry Millenial, but I think you're positioning yourself on the wrong side of history on this one.
This video is the only one on this channel that I haven’t liked so far. As a matter of fact, this is really sloppy and one sided.
Unions always ask for more than they expect to get, that’s what bargaining is. You don’t go into a negotiation asking for what you want or think is feasible, because the other side will talk you down from there. That’s a huge part at play in the negotiating process which you have completely ignored.
That “rounding error” you describe is egregious. If big companies want to pay this much for office workers (not to mention the perks like stock options and huge severance packages) the optics are fucking terrible for any of the wage workers. CEO’s do not work 28,000 times harder than the factory workers do, and if they didn’t want these optics to get factored into striking unions this should be adjusted.
I also didn’t like how your comparison between the CEO and the workers included the benefits packages and other non wage expenses for the workers but only included the salary of the CEO. Again, this is lazy and one sided. If that’s just a “rounding error” then why not have more “rounding errors” to favour the broader employee base?
You also referenced the lower wages of workers in Europe and Japan. Fun fact about both those places: they have public healthcare and a massive slew of social programs that help with the cost of living and provide a safety net if employment terminates. This could easily be the reason why wages in these other countries don’t need to be as high, but the tax burden of any of these manufacturing facilities would be higher in each of these places, offsetting the lower wages paid to employees in these regions.
I could keep going, but I think I’ve proved my point. I’m glad the unions and the automakers have been able to come to an agreement that works for everyone, and I’m glad the union pushed when it did.
Workers need to learn a lesson from the British automaker industry. The British went from the largest in the world outside the USA, then the unions demanded more pay, the companies gave them more pay, but the productivity did not go up and the quality went down. Your government needs to step in.
No, they are going to take the work to Mexico. When that happenes there going to crie and say our jobs are gone
This is hopeless, American companies are being hamstrung by government regulation and unionization, meanwhile Chinese automakers pay their workers dirt and make low quality shite. American companies will be forced to shut down, and all of your crap will be designed and produced by Chinamen who don't give a single f about you or your rights
This is an awful analysis. I would put this one in the dumpster ASAP
Disappointed by this production! This is a misrepresentation. I was shocked at the current wages of even the most experienced workers. That is less than what I made as an intern right after college doing what monkeys could do.
1.4% dues for 10-20% extra pay is limited value?
Tell me youve never worked a blue collar job without telling me youve never worked a blue collar job
The problem is regular people need more money. Not $3 slave wages from mexico and not the $17 they make now. All those col adjustments and health/pension packages that kept up with inflation need to be reinstated. It's ridiculous that inflation is increasing yet workers must suffer. Wtf is that?
Musk despite his flaws, thinks that competition is important.
You are really full of it if you sympathize with the leadership of those companies.
Why shouldn't they suffer salary loss like the workers did ? Why shouldn't they compensate workers for years of salaries not being readjusted ?
You have to be a privileged white male to even consider adhering to that line of thinking, and excuse the irresponsible selfish behavior of those people.
they put plants in Mexico and cars didnt get any cheaper,why workers must subsidize shareholders and management?
. workers generate 100 percent of profit
Tesla car manufacturer wages in California is only in the 20s range this is one of the many reasons Tesla has high turnover.
We will tell future generations what it was like to drive a Ford or a Chevy and see them everywhere. These cancerous organizations are already lost due to the poison of unions. Just let them go under and no more bailouts
Anyone watch that Netflix show of the Chinese auto glass factory coming to America? The ceo made a big deal about giving jobs, then being surprised the workers joined a union after being paid $10/hr and having Chinese supervisors berating them at every chance saying efficiency was too low.
And people wonder why jobs are moving out of the country…
And this sports fans is why everyone will probably end up driving Toyotas.
In globalised economy, the unions serve only one purpuso, to destroy the western industry leftovers.
The Unions should be banned as a cartel and replaced by higher minimum wage that will increase by inflation or gdp growth.
I would love these executives to show the cost basis of their increases in the last 3 years….I am going to bet it was not due to labor costs.
USD 150 per hour?
They are dreaming.