In most states in the US Tesla is banned from selling cars directly to consumers. The bans are justified by 100 year old laws designed to protect independent dealerships from unfair competition from automobile manufacturers. Tesla does not use any independent dealerships so it makes no sense for the laws to be applied to Tesla. Nevertheless car dealership associations across the country have done everything in their power to make sure these laws are applied to Tesla. Despite this disadvantage, Tesla is still growing rapidly and taking share from the traditional auto makers.
Support us on Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/WallStreetMillennial
Check out our website: http://wallstreetmillennial.com/
Join our free Discord Server: https://discord.gg/VBd6cA4jUt
Twitter: https://twitter.com/MillennialWall
#WallStreetMillenial #Tesla
Music courtesy of:
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––
Buddha by Kontekst https://soundcloud.com/kontekstmusic
Creative Commons — Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported — CC BY-SA 3.0
Free Download / Stream: http://bit.ly/2Pe7mBN
Music promoted by Audio Library https://youtu.be/b6jK2t3lcRs
––––––––––––––––––––––––––––––

What's up guys and welcome back to wall street millennial on this channel, we cover everything related to stocks and investing over the past few years, electric vehicles have disrupted the traditional automotive industry. Ev sales went from zero percent of total automobile sales in 2010 to almost 3. In 2019, while this might not sound like a lot is expected to increase exponentially over the next couple decades. A big part of this growth has come from tesla, which revolutionized the industry by providing affordable mass market ev's with the successful launch of their mass market model.

3 and model y tesla's sales have surged and they stand on track to make close to 1 million deliveries in 2021. Despite the global chip shortage, but not everybody is happy about tesla's success. Since inception, tesla has had to fight against corrupt established business interests, who have done everything in their power to see the company fail, despite their best efforts and entrenched advantages. Tesla is still beating them at their own game.

If you want to buy a car from pretty much any brand besides tesla, your only option is to go to a dealership in your local community. If you've bought a new car recently, you probably didn't have a great experience. You were probably greeted by an eager sales person who immediately tried to sell you the most expensive internal combustion engine car in the building. They'll also try to sell you a bunch of financing and insurance items that you don't really understand and probably don't need.

In theory, you can negotiate to try to get a better price, but when you're up against a professional salesperson, who's doing these types of negotiations for years, most people don't stand a chance. A nationwide poll conducted by harris in 2016 found that 87 percent of americans dislike something about the car buying experience and 60 percent of americans feel taken advantage of when they shop at a car dealership. The goal of a car company is to sell as many cars as possible, so it seems weird that they make a retail sales system, that's almost universally despised by consumers. A big part of the reason for this is that the dealerships aren't owned by the manufacturers they're.

Instead, owned by third-party franchises authorized to sell cars for certain brands, in fact, almost everywhere in the u.s, it is illegal for automobile manufacturers to directly sell cars to consumers. They are required by law to use independent dealerships. So why is this the case and how does it relate to tesla the laws? Restricting ownership of car dealerships dates back to the 1930s. Their purpose was to protect independent car dealerships from unfair competition from the automakers.

The idea is that an independent dealership might spend many years developing the ford brand, for example, in their local community. Ford could set up their own dealership in the same community and undercut the independent dealership on price. Thus, they'd be able to steal all the market share without having done the hard work of establishing the brand. The current franchise system in america is extremely inefficient.
The dealership needs to earn a profit margin on each car. They sell so they charge a markup over the price they buy it from from the manufacturer. Goldman sachs estimates that consumers could see end prices reduced by as much as 10 percent if the dealership system were abolished and manufacturers could sell directly to consumers. Despite this inefficiency, the american automobile market has functioned in this way for the better part of the past 100 years.

But then tesla showed up to disrupt the entire system. Tesla doesn't use independent dealerships. All of their sales are directly to consumer consumers can order a tesla directly from the tesla website. The prices are transparent and non-negotiable, so there's no need to haggle with a salesperson.

They'll deliver the card directly to your home, so you never need to walk into a dealership. So why does tesla use the direct sales system instead of using independent dealerships, like everyone else? Part of this is because they make the majority of their profit, not by selling new cars, but instead by providing services and repairs down the line. Electric vehicles are much simpler internally than internal combustion engine cars and have fewer moving parts. They also don't need oil changes.

This is great for the consumer, but disaster for the car dealership because they make the majority of their money through aftermarket services. There's a clear conflict of interest. The dealership will almost always recommend an ice car, even when an ev would be more appropriate to a consumer. Also, tesla's strategy has long been to vertically integrate as much of the value chain as possible.

This gives them more power over the consumer experience and it means that they internalize all the profit margins selling directly to consumers puts tesla at a huge advantage from a profitability perspective because they don't have to share any of the value with the independent dealerships. Tesla's success with direct-to-consumer sales represents an existential threat for the car dealerships. When people realize they can save a lot of time and hassle by buying cars directly from the tesla website, they will realize that independent dealerships probably don't need to exist, but the car dealerships weren't about to go down without a fight car dealership associations in almost every State have sued tesla over the years to try to ban them from selling directly to consumers. Currently, tesla is banned from directly selling to consumers in more than half of the states in america.

This includes texas, where they are building a gigafactory. The dealerships invoke long-standing laws prohibiting automobile manufacturers from directly competing with dealerships, and while they do technically have a legal grounding, they're completely distorting the spirit of the law for their own monetary gain. The entire purpose of these laws was to prevent auto manufacturers from unfairly competing against their own franchise dealerships and stealing the brand equity that they built in the local community when these laws were being drafted in the 1930s legislators didn't even consider a car company like tesla, Which doesn't use independent franchise dealers at all? It is impossible for tesla to unfairly compete against its franchisees because they don't have any. Thus, it makes no sense for tesla to have to abide by these hundred year old laws.
Car dealerships are major employers in almost every state and they thus have a lot of influence on state-level politics. Car dealership associations across the country spend millions of dollars on lobbying campaigns to influence legislation to be as unfavorable as possible for tesla. Even though tesla is banned from directly selling to consumers in most states, they have successfully found ways to get around these restrictions. If a consumer buys a tesla online and tesla ships it to them out of state, this is considered.

Interstate commerce and state laws cannot ban this through this method. Tesla has been able to get around the draconian restrictions to sell to consumers in every state, but it is still a painful thorn and tesla's side. Once giga texas is producing cars, they will have to be shipped outside of the state and re-shipped back in whenever a texas resident wants to buy a tesla. This is because texas did not allow direct sales to consumers, so they have to make an interstate transaction to get around this.

This just goes to show how absurd and efficient these laws are, while it's possible to order online. Many consumers want to see the car in person and test drive it before making a 50 000 purchase in states where it's allowed. Tesla has stores where consumers can buy the car directly in some states, such as texas, which do not allow tesla to directly sell cars. Tesla sets up galleries instead at the galleries.

Consumers can view the cars in person and ask a sales person about its features. However, they're not allowed to buy the car or talk about pricing in any way. Tesla revolutionized the auto industry, by cutting out the middleman of independent dealerships and going directly to the consumer and despite the incumbent's best efforts to stop them, tesla is winning. Consumers far prefer the simple process of ordering a tesla online and having it delivered to them.

The prices are transparent and they don't feel taken advantage of by a salesman at a dealership. This has allowed tesla to continue taking market share from the legacy automakers and, by extension, their dealerships and, in recent years, tesla's been winning at the courts as well. In almost all the blue states on this map, where tesla is allowed to sell directly, they had to earn this victory through years of battles and courts and state legislatures. Also in 2021, tesla is teaming up with rivien, lucid and lordstown motors to lobby state governments to formally allow direct selling.
It seems like the eevee makers are finally winning in the fight against the legacy. Auto establishment, alright guys that wraps it up for this video. What do you think about the independent car dealerships? Do you think it's reasonable that tesla is still not allowed to sell directly to consumers in more than half of the states in the us? Let us know in the comments section below, if you enjoyed this content, make sure to hit the like button and subscribe. So you don't miss future uploads as always.

Thank you so much for watching and we'll see in the next one wall, street millennial signing out.

By Stock Chat

where the coffee is hot and so is the chat

27 thoughts on “How car dealerships tried and failed to ban tesla”
  1. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars K Roddy says:

    I remember walking into the international mall in Tampa back when Tesla's share price was in the low $200s and thinking about buying like 20 shares I didn't 😒 second worse decision other than me buying VTI in a Roth rather than Amazon when Amazon was $215 a share. Finger was on the button of the mouse, than I heard Jim Cramer go on and on about them not being profitable 🤦.

  2. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars ℛɛᴛʀᴏ ℛɛᴅ says:

    The downside to owning a Tesla is that you can't fix it yourself. I love fixing my own car, I don't go to the dealership or a mechanic.

  3. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Rex Mann says:

    Factories sell the cars for about 5-10k the rest is profit for the dealership. This law created minions for the big car companies. Thank you government.

  4. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars E says:

    Old laws that need updating. Remember laws catch up depending on what consumer behavior is doing. Sooner or later legacy dealerships and manufacturers won't be able to do anything as change becomes inevitable.

  5. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Jack Che says:

    Imagine other auto makers can direct sale. Many will lose jobs and real estate values. Its a disasters but it makes more sense.

  6. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Parzival says:

    Bought a Tesla early this year and it was the best car buying experience I’ve ever had

  7. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Antonio Maglione says:

    There is a scheme here in Europe, where one customer leave the dealership is a SUV while paying a monthly amount of money that normally would pay for a small city car. I call this scheme "Ride now, cry later", because the customer – after three years, at the end of the low monthly payments, must pay half of the price of the large car all together, or surrender the car, with nothing due back.
    And it is not all. The customer must agree to not drive more than 10k km in the period, and to pay (without appeal) for damages like dirty seats or paint scratches, and avoid excessive use of brake pads and clutch disk; these can amount to many thousands at the end of the period.
    It is unbelievable how many people fall in this trap; mainly because of their vanity, they find themselves at the wheel not of a car, but of a massive liability, forced to ask friends to remove their shoes when it rains, before they ride their car…
    The freedom you are entitled in an old banger, you won't believe!

  8. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Sight Seeing says:

    Tesla didn't invent selling cars to consumers lol. The laws existed from all the other people who tried it. Delorean and Studebaker comes to mind

  9. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Fox says:

    Car dealership are one of those needlessly restrictive business areas with a now totally useless middleman

  10. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars merced175 says:

    This also happened in the malls. Tesla had a ground breaking new strategy to sell their cars in malls. I have one near my home town in the Brea mall. Then, the car industry lobbied to make it illegal to open a car dealership in malls because they were threatened by such a good strategy. You can still find tesla stores in places where they were built before the ban was put into effect.

  11. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Kha Le says:

    Going to a car dealer is like being thrown into a room full of pickpockets with money inside your jacket and try to survive for the next 5 hours.

  12. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Thaddeus J. Pumpernickel says:

    I learned long ago how to deal with pushy car salesmen: "Stop talking. You can either sell me the vehicle I'm interested in or I can go elsewhere. Got it?" Yes, it's rude as hell, but it shuts their bulls**t down real quick.

  13. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars James Hoffman says:

    I only bought two new cars Before Tesla ('BT'), and both were bad experiences — not horrible in themselves, but leaving me regretting that I'd gotten a bad deal. In contrast, I look forward to my interactions with Tesla staff, not just because they don't take advantage of me financially, but Tesla staff is different — as if we're part of the same team (true in my case being a shareholder).

  14. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars TheOtherGuy says:

    How do I test drive a tesla? while yeah it's nice to buy online is it comfortable to me is the question.

  15. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Telcontar1962 says:

    All this describes is just how much political power is being put behind the most fraudulent corporation I'm human history

    Abd to say that it really has to go some to beat the competition when one looks at the arms industry.

    Musk acts untouchable gecayse he knows he is. Not because of the dud product he's able to push but because ifbthe high powered corrupt political establishment behind him.

  16. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Zeke Bones says:

    I would love to see every car dealership in America go under, that’s how much I hate them

  17. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Antonio Maglione says:

    Liked your video, as still has both thumb up and thumb down. As a personal form of protest against YT, I'm not voting anymore the videos without the thumb down counter; I rather leave a note in the comment.
    Thanks for the video. Living in Europe, I didn't know about Tesla and the car dealers in the US. Yes, I avoid going to a car dealer even if I need to buy a car. Yes, the US dealership law needs an update…

  18. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Armando Sanchez says:

    Tesla production is slow . Why would car manufacturers care ? Car rental ordered 100 thousand by 2025 Tesla lol

  19. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars nisetsu says:

    I always thought it was infuriating that you can't buy a car directly from the factory and you are forced to give some asshole a month's salary when buying a car for no other reason than it is tradition. Tesla only does what we should have been doing since internet became a thing, actually we could have been doing it over the phone all along. Order car, send check, get call when your car is ready, go pick it up from the factory.

  20. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Bruh Man says:

    Their vehicles are great from what I see and I would want one if I get an electric car, but their business practices are a deal breaker unfortunately.

  21. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Charles williams says:

    <Many people have been complaining about trading, trading is an art that requires maximum focus and attention. Trading is a lucrative opportunity as it leverages the market volatility and right now is a good time to take advantage of the market. This is because the market is unpredictable, and traders must react quickly to price moves. Also, in the absence of these two key ingredients, a trader might suffer a huge loss. Newbie traders also have a knack for seeking inspiration from established traders. I have been trading cryptocurrency for a while now but I was only able to make 16.3ƁƬƇ in 27days trading with signals from Jefferson Davies, a renowned trader that is always one step ahead. Jefferson Davies can easily be reached on Tєlєɠгคm as [Davies481>>>

  22. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars James Hoffman says:

    Tesla's relationship with its customers is like that with its employees — aligned rather than adversarial. In much the same way that Tesla employees are made stakeholders through stock options, owners tend to feel common cause with the company as well — partly because the product itself is so awesome, but also because you can participate in development efforts like FSD. I look forward to all my interactions with team Tesla, and I can tell they appreciate me (perhaps from the length of my order book — lots of FSD-optioned CyberTrucks).

  23. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars DavidJMa says:

    The dealers get loads of 'factory money' from the brand owner to shift volume too.

  24. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars アンディアンディ says:

    Not all dealerships are horrible last year I bought a 2018 Honda Civic with 20k miles for $11k

  25. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Vanishing Act - says:

    Buying a car at most American dealerships is about as pleasant as getting a prostate exam or a colonoscopy. I understand that a lot of peoples livelihoods depend on this inefficient sales model, but there should be some way to make the experience more pleasant for the consumer.

  26. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Brandon J says:

    I don’t think many people would complain about buying from dealerships if they weren’t such a negative atmosphere connected to them. No one enjoys dealing with dealership salespeople. Once again, greed takes precedent.

  27. Avataaar/Circle Created with python_avatars Connor says:

    Dealerships are like estate agents.

    Functionally useless and can be replaced by a comparison website yet persist due to tradition and lobbying

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.